Blog #1 Maybe We Don't Need to Become Experts First
I have always been interested in the difference between knowing something and actually being able to do something. Think about how often we describe ourselves this way. I'm not a math person. I'm not a science person. I'm not athletic. I'm not a good reader. I have definitely heard students say things like this, and I think many adults have probably said something similar about themselves (including me and maybe you?). Buehl's discussion of disciplinary literacy made me think about why this happens. Reading is not exactly the same in every subject. A student needs to learn how to approach a text through the practices of a particular discipline. A historian, for example, might ask different questions of a text than a scientist would. and they emphasized on asking students to develop “habits of thinking” like an expert and instead propose “habits of practice.” If we tell a student to “think like a scientist,” we might accidentally make the student wonder whether they...